Serving Central Illinois since 1964

Great food and great service

don't happen by accident

Pagliai's Pizza – Authentic Pizza | Charleston, IL Pizza Pizza

Authentic Pizza Like No Other

Quality ingredients

Enjoy incredible pizza made using only the freshest ingredients at Pagliai's Pizza. Whether you're dining in or picking up an order for takeout, you can count on a locally owned and operated restaurant to provide you with a dining experience like no other.

Enjoy exquisite cuisine made fresh daily using local produce and meats; all sausages and cheeses are made fresh on premises.

Check out our menu

Delivery available

Exceptional service

Treat yourself to amazing pizza and more at our restaurant. With over 50 years of experience, you know you're in good hands.

See what customers have to say about us

Open seven days a week

Enjoy your favorite dishes whenever you like; we're open seven days a week for your convenience. Stop by and see us today!

Visit our restaurant

Let great food come to you when you place an order for delivery!

Pizza Pasta Sandwiches